- The Faithful Historian
- Posts
- The Borgias - Chapter 5
The Borgias - Chapter 5
The Spider's Web: Borgia Diplomacy
As the first light of dawn crept over the Seven Hills of Rome, Pope Alexander VI stood at the window of his private chambers, his eyes red-rimmed from a sleepless night. The death of Alfonso of Aragon hung over the Vatican like a shroud, whispers of murder and conspiracy echoing through its hallowed halls.
Yet even as Rome reeled from the scandal, the Pope's mind was already weaving new plans, spinning a web of alliances that would elevate the Borgia family to unprecedented heights of power.
In the weeks that followed, as summer gave way to autumn, Alexander moved swiftly to contain the damage. Lucrezia was sequestered in the convent of San Sisto, ostensibly to mourn her husband but also to shield her from the storm of rumors. Meanwhile, Cesare Borgia, fresh from his conquests in the Romagna, strode through the Vatican as if daring anyone to accuse him of involvement in Alfonso's death.
The Pope knew that to secure his family's position, he needed to act boldly. With France already in his pocket thanks to Cesare's marriage and military alliance, Alexander turned his gaze towards Spain. The Catholic Monarchs, Ferdinand, and Isabella were a formidable power, and their support could prove crucial in the coming years.

Wedding portrait of Queen Isabella I and King Ferdinand II of Aragon, married in 1469
In the grand audience chamber of the Apostolic Palace, its walls adorned with frescoes depicting the triumphs of past popes, Alexander received the Spanish ambassador. The air was thick with incense and intrigue as the two men engaged in a delicate dance of diplomacy.
"Your Holiness," the ambassador began, his voice echoing in the cavernous room, "Their Catholic Majesties are concerned about the growing French influence in Italy. They seek assurances of Your Holiness's continued friendship."
Alexander smiled, a gesture that did not quite reach his eyes. "Spain has always been close to our heart," he replied smoothly. "Perhaps a union between our families would set their minds at ease?"
The bait was set. Over the coming months, negotiations unfolded for a marriage between Lucrezia Borgia and Alfonso d'Este, son of the Duke of Ferrara. The Este family, while not as powerful as the Spanish monarchy, were influential in their own right and strategically located between papal and French territories.
As winter descended on Rome, bringing with it a chill that seemed to seep into the very stones of the city, the marriage contract was finalized. Lucrezia, still pale from her confinement but with a determined glint in her eye, prepared for her third marriage.
The wedding, held in December 1501, was a spectacle of unprecedented grandeur. The streets of Rome were festooned with garlands and tapestries, the air filled with the sound of trumpets and the cheers of the populace. Lucrezia, resplendent in a gown of gold brocade studded with pearls, rode through the city on a white palfrey, her golden hair shimmering in the winter sun.
In St. Peter's Basilica, as Alexander VI himself performed the marriage rite, the assembled nobility of Italy watched with a mixture of awe and trepidation. The Borgia star was ascendant, and none could predict where its rise would end.

Portrait d'Alphonse dEste - Titien Inv.1053
Meanwhile, Cesare Borgia continued his military campaigns with ruthless efficiency. City after city in the Papal States fell to his forces, their ancient ruling families toppled and replaced with Borgia loyalists. Urbino, Camerino, Senigallia - all succumbed to the Duke of Valentinois's irresistible advance.
In the conquered territories, Cesare instituted reforms that won him the support of the common people. He lowered taxes, improved infrastructure, and established a more equitable justice system. Yet behind these benevolent actions lay an iron fist, ready to crush any hint of rebellion.
By the summer of 1502, at a grand ceremony in Rome's Piazza Navona, Cesare was officially invested as Duke of Romagna. The square, transformed into a sea of Borgia crimson and gold, resounded with cheers as Alexander VI placed the ducal cap on his son's head.
"Behold," the Pope proclaimed, his voice carrying across the crowded plaza, "the sword of the Church and the shield of Italy!"
But even as the Borgias celebrated their triumphs, dark clouds were gathering on the horizon. In Venice, Doge Agostino Barbarigo and the formidable Council of Ten watched the expansion of Borgia power with growing alarm. Barbarigo, who had ruled the Venetian Republic since 1486, was known for his shrewd diplomacy and commitment to maintaining Venice's power in the face of changing Italian politics.
The Council of Ten, a secretive and powerful body consisting of ten elected members, six ducal councilors, and the Doge himself, met in closed sessions to discuss the Borgia threat. This council, with its vast network of spies and diplomats, had broad authority over state security and public order. They feared that Cesare's conquests in the Romagna might eventually threaten their mainland territories, crucial to Venice's commercial empire.
In Florence, despite an alliance with Cesare, a rising political star named Niccolò Machiavelli penned worried dispatches about the changing balance of power in Italy. Machiavelli, serving as Second Chancellor of the Florentine Republic, had met Cesare Borgia during diplomatic missions and was both impressed and terrified by the duke's ruthless efficiency.

Portrait of Niccolò Machiavelli (c. 1500)
Machiavelli's reports to the Florentine government were filled with astute observations of Cesare's methods. He wrote, "The Duke Valentino's actions show a man of extraordinary prowess; he can be considered a new power in Italy." However, Machiavelli also warned of the danger this new power posed to the independence of Italian states, including Florence itself. These experiences would later form the basis for his seminal work, "The Prince," in which Cesare would feature prominently as a model of political cunning.
Most ominously, in the French court, King Louis XII began to question the wisdom of supporting Cesare's ambitions. The Borgia duke, once a useful ally in Louis's Italian campaigns, was rapidly becoming a potential rival for control of northern Italy. The King, who had provided crucial military support for Cesare's conquests, now found himself in the awkward position of having aided the creation of a formidable new power on the Italian peninsula.
As autumn approached once again, bringing with it a harvest of grapes for Rome's famous wines, a secret meeting took place in a shadowy chamber of the Doge's Palace in Venice. Representatives from France, Spain, the Holy Roman Empire, and several Italian states gathered to discuss the growing Borgia threat.
In Rome, blissfully unaware of the storm brewing beyond the horizon, Alexander VI stood on the balcony of St. Peter's, surveying the Eternal City that now seemed to be firmly in his grasp. Beside him, Cesare looked out over the same vista, his eyes already fixed on new conquests.
But in the narrow streets below, amid the bustle of daily life, a whisper began to spread. A whisper of change, of gathering forces, of a reckoning to come. The spider's web of Borgia diplomacy, so carefully woven, was about to face its greatest test.
As night fell over Rome, the air thick with the scent of ripening figs and distant wood smoke, the stage was set for a confrontation that would shake the foundations of Renaissance Italy. What forces were aligning against the Borgias? And could even the cunning of Alexander VI and the military prowess of Cesare withstand the coming storm?
[To be continued in next week's installment...]